Difference between bien, bueno, buen

edited March 2013 in Spanish
Hola!

What are the differences between bien, bueno, and buen?  In what types of cases do you use one or another?

Comments

  • Bien is an adverb, so it's used much as English uses well.

    Buen is the shortened form of bueno that's used right before a masculine singular noun: un buen libro (a good book) but este libro es bueno (this book is good).

    (With my normal caveat that I'm not a native speaker, and Anna will have the definitive answer! But I think that's more or less the story.)
  • edited March 2013
    Hi there!

    That is right Chris,

    Bien is an adverb (meaning well) and buen is an adjective (meaning good)

    - Lo hiciste bien. (You did it well)

    Buen is used in from of a masculine noun, while bueno/a is used after the noun:

    - Fue un buen viaje. (It was a good trip)
    - El viaje fue bueno. (The trip was good)


    As a general rule, adjectives generally go after the noun, and the sentence will have a more literal meaning. When coming before a noun, an adjective generally takes on a more figurative, poetic, or literary sense.
  • Muchas Gracias.
  • I have another question along these lines.  When someone wants to say "that's good", or "that's OK" I will sometimes hear "esta bien" and sometimes "es bueno."  What is the difference?  When do you use one or the other?  I understand that bien describes a verb and buen/bueno describes a noun.
  • Hi Carrie !

    I'll try to answer that one.
    You would use es or esta' depending on whether you are using the verb ser or estar.
    If you are describing permanent quality, you will use ser(es). 
    for eg. How is the movie? - Co'mo es la peli'cula?
    It is good - Es bueno. 
    On the other hand, if you are describing temporary qualities, you use estar(esta').
    for eg. How is he? - Co'mo esta'?
    He is fine - E'l esta' bien

    I hope this helps.

    Mahima
  • Hello Carrie and Mahima!

    Mahima you are right about using ser or estar for permanent qualities or temporary qualities.  Another student asked a similar question in the Spanish Forum and I wrote a quick guide on when to use SER or ESTAR.



    Here are some examples to understand when to use (Está bien/ Está bueno / Es bueno)

    "Está bien" - means "No problem, is ok".

    Pedro - Lo siento mucho  (I am really sorry)
    Juan - Está bién  (It is ok)

    You can also use "está bien" to express "It is right/correct":
    :
    - La respuesta del ejercicio está bién. - The test answer is right/correct

    "Es bueno" -  describes a quality that is consistent and does not tend to change.

    - Ramón es bueno (Ramón is a good guy)
    - Desayunar es bueno (To eat breakfast is good for you)

    "Está bueno" - describes a quality that is temporary or can change.

    - El desayuno está bueno (Breakfast is good today)

  • Muchas gracias.
Sign In to comment.